Land Right Issues Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words

Land Right Issues - Essay Example The most interesting interpretation of this right of return is that the Israeli Jews are to be blamed for the present predicament of all Palestinian diaspora as a result of the establishment of Israeli State and Zionism (Beinin and Rebbecca 68). Under such an interpretation, liability for the Palestinian quandary can only be correctly carried out by allowing all the Palestinians in the diaspora to return to their original homeland and evicting all the Jews who live in such areas, more so those who gained these lands as a result of Zionism. An antithesis to such an interpretation of Jewish accountability for the predicament of the Palestinians is the total denial of any such forms of responsibility as well as the complete rejection of the return of the Palestinians. These are the two key positions of the dilemma, between which several intermediate possibilities lie. A central intermediate position tends to agree with the reasoning that all or part of the Palestinian diaspora should go to Israel within the scope of the Palestine pre-1967 borders. The Israelis are against this position, though they see it is a worthy step toward reconciling them with Palestinians. In this case, the issue of distributive justice is evidently in play. This concerns what some people believe to be socially correct with regard to resources allocation in a given society. In the book A Theory of Justice, John Rawls makes efforts of solving the dilemma of distributive justice by using an alternative of the much familiar social contract device.